A leadership crisis has erupted in The Fountain of Life Church, Lagos, following conflicting statements over the purported removal of Pastor Jimmy Odukoya as its Senior Pastor.
While a statement attributed to the church’s Board of Trustees announced that Odukoya had been removed over alleged disregard for the succession instructions of his late father and church founder, Pastor Taiwo Odukoya, another statement issued in the name of the church rejected the announcement, insisting that Jimmy remained in office.
The development has raised questions about the leadership structure of the church, the authority of its trustees and the circumstances surrounding the succession arrangements made before the founder’s death in August 2023.
In a statement issued on Tuesday, the church described the purported removal of Jimmy as constitutionally invalid, arguing that the announcement did not represent a valid decision of its Board of Trustees.
The statement, which was not signed by any individual, accused a group of persons describing themselves as “Concerned Members of the Board” of making pronouncements outside the church’s constitutional framework.
It urged members of the congregation, the media and the general public to disregard statements that did not reflect the church’s constitutionally authorised position.
The church maintained that Jimmy’s appointment as Senior Pastor and Chairman of the Board of Trustees was unanimously approved in September 2023, following the death of his father.
It further stated that no constitutionally valid decision had been taken to remove him from either position.
According to the statement, some trustees had been asked to resign on March 14, 2026, over alleged repeated violations of the church’s constitution and founding principles.
The latest development followed an earlier report by Breezy News that the Board of Trustees had withdrawn its recognition of Jimmy as Senior Pastor after reviewing the church’s constitution and a video recording of instructions allegedly left by the late founder.
In the statement announcing his removal, the trustees said the appointment of Jimmy in 2023 was made in good faith to ensure continuity following the founder’s death but was based on what they subsequently described as incomplete information about his succession wishes.
The board claimed it had recently discovered a video recording made in December 2021, in which Taiwo reportedly communicated his preferred succession arrangement.
According to the account, the recording was made by Jimmy at his father’s request and witnessed by other persons but was not presented to the trustees when they sought information about any instructions left by the founder.
The trustees alleged that the recording identified another person as Taiwo’s preferred successor, while Jimmy was assigned responsibilities as an assistant to the designated successor on administrative matters and head of the youth church.
The board said its review of the recording, the circumstances surrounding its creation and the church’s constitution convinced it that the late founder had exercised his authority to determine the succession arrangement before his death.
It consequently declared that Jimmy was no longer recognised as the church’s Senior Pastor with immediate effect.
The trustees’ position suggests that the disagreement goes beyond the personality of the current church leader, touching on the interpretation of the founder’s wishes and whether the succession process followed after his death complied with the church’s governing provisions.
A major issue is the status of the December 2021 recording and the circumstances under which it was allegedly made. While the trustees insist that the video contains clear instructions from the founder, the counter-statement raises questions about the authority of those relying on it to announce a change in leadership.
The church’s constitution is also central to the dispute. The two statements present sharply different interpretations of the powers and procedures available to the Board of Trustees, particularly concerning the appointment and removal of the Senior Pastor.
The distinction is important because the announcement of a leadership change by a section of trustees does not, by itself, establish that the process has met the requirements of the church’s constitution. Equally, the church’s rejection of the announcement leaves unresolved the question of how the alleged succession instructions should be treated.
The trustees also raised concerns about Jimmy’s recent remarriage and its public blessing, describing the development as inconsistent with the church’s teachings, the founders’ values and the standards expected of its spiritual leadership.
They said the issue, alongside other developments, had caused concern among members and exposed the church to public controversy.
The inclusion of his remarriage in the statement announcing his removal has introduced another dimension to the disagreement, bringing questions about personal conduct, church doctrine and the expectations attached to pastoral leadership into the wider controversy.
However, the counter-statement attributed to the church challenged the legitimacy of the removal announcement, insisting that the group behind it lacked the constitutional authority to speak for the institution.
By maintaining that Jimmy’s appointment was unanimously approved in September 2023, the church effectively questioned the basis on which the trustees sought to reverse that decision. Its reference to the March 14, 2026 request for some trustees to resign also indicates that disagreements within the church’s governing structure may have preceded the latest public confrontation.
The circumstances surrounding those alleged requests for resignation, including the identities of the trustees involved and the specific constitutional provisions said to have been breached, were not detailed in the unsigned statement.
Neither statement, as presented, has provided sufficient independent information to settle the competing claims. The contents of the alleged video recording, the relevant constitutional provisions and the precise resolutions taken by the trustees remain important to establishing the validity of either position.
The conflicting positions have brought the church’s internal leadership disagreements into the public domain, with the central issues now revolving around the interpretation of its constitution, the authority of the Board of Trustees and the validity of the succession instructions allegedly left by its late founder.
Taiwo and his wife, Bimbo Odukoya, founded The Fountain of Life Church in 1992. Over the years, the church established a significant presence in Nigeria’s Pentecostal community, with its ministry extending beyond regular worship services to leadership development, family life and other social initiatives.
Taiwo remained the church’s central spiritual and administrative figure until his death in August 2023. His passing created the need for a succession arrangement to ensure continuity in the leadership of an institution he had built over several decades.
Jimmy, who succeeded his father following his death, has also maintained a public profile through his pastoral responsibilities and activities in the entertainment industry. His emergence as Senior Pastor was seen as part of the transition following the founder’s demise, although the latest controversy has now placed the circumstances of that appointment under scrutiny.
For a church that has operated for more than three decades, the current disagreement presents a significant test of its institutional structures and ability to resolve internal disputes without further damaging the confidence of its congregation.
For now, the conflicting statements have left members and observers with competing accounts of who has the legitimate authority to lead the church, as questions remain over the authenticity, interpretation and constitutional implications of the alleged succession recording.
Until the church’s constitutionally recognised governing organs clarify their positions and provide a definitive account of the decisions taken, uncertainty over its leadership is likely to persist.



